12/3/17

Mack’s Apple’s – Dominic Smith, Robert Gsellman, Braves Prospects, Curt Schilling, Future of Baseball



Good morning.



Dominic Smith discusses exit meeting with Mets GM Sandy Alderson:  ‘I left it motivated’ -

“We had a great conversation. We both agreed that I didn’t perform like I would like, and like he said, the job isn’t mine. It’s not secured, it’s not mine. I didn’t leave that meeting upset or hurt or mad or angry. I left it motivated,” Smith said Monday night in a sitdown with SNY. “I’m not taking anything for granted. I know I didn’t perform like I know I’m capable of. I know I didn’t perform like I would like and I’m definitely going to work my butt off this spring training. I’m going to spring training in shape and going to spring training ready to win a job.”

I’ve been rough on Dom in the past, mostly over his lack of home run production in the minors. I wasn’t alone in this criticism and I hope me and the other writers didn’t cause Smith to hit the heavy weights and come to camp last year as solid as a rock..

Muscle alone doesn’t mean your home runs will increase. The angle of your bat to the ball does. My guess is the Mets coaching staff caused this change, not Dom.

Trust me. Dom can hit. He can also field. All he needs to do is let his confidence take over his game and return to what he does naturally.

I expect him on the Mets first base on opening day 2018.


What does Justin Birnbaum have against Mets pitcher  Robert Gsellman -



The Mets are not a better team in 2018 with Gsellman in their rotation or even serving as rotational depth. The way the club has thrown his name around loosely in trade talks signals that he is not of much value to Sandy Alderson and his team. Best case scenario for the 24-year-old is a long-relief role in the bullpen, but Gsellman would be hard pressed to even make the roster coming out of camp this year. Unfortunately, Robert Gsellman was a shooting star for this club and his time has come and gone.





Most Players Skipped MLB’s Workout For  Former Braves Prospects  -

Major League Baseball held a showcase today in the Dominican Republic for the 12 former Braves prospects whose contracts the league voided, but most of the players did not show up.

Of the 12 players, just three—outfielders Antonio Sucre and Brandol Mezquita and shortstop Angel Rojas—were at the workout, which was at Estadio Quisqueya in Santo Domingo. According to multiple sources, several players did not show up to the workout because they are in the middle of their offseason and felt that MLB did not give them sufficient time to prepare themselves to be showcased for clubs.


Curt Schilling and the Baseball Hall of Fame: What’s the Issue? –

It’s a simple concept. Journalists are supposed to be impartial, and their job is to cover baseball games — so they should have the proper judgment to make the picks. For the most part, the concept has worked well for the past 78 years. But then there’s Curt Schilling. Schilling has become well-known nationally ever since his baseball career ended because of his outspoken political beliefs. Today he's an internet radio host for Breitbart News — a position he took after ESPN fired him in April 2016.

Wait. There’s no politics allowed on Mack’s Mets.

Sorry.

  Doctor in Cumming is trying to change the future of baseball –

Tim Griffith sits in his scrubs in a lightly adorned examination room at Peachtree Orthopedics' Cumming office, the same space where earlier in the day he saw a patient who had pitched in four baseball games in four days. In Griffith's view, that's not right. A pitcher, especially one who's young and still growing, should not be throwing that much and putting his arm at serious risk for future injury. A bigger problem is that Griffith, an orthopedic surgeon who's been with Peachtree since 2014, is seeing cases like that more and more, with the resulting injuries stacking up. "Oh, there's no question that it's an epidemic," Griffith said.

Griffith is an Atlanta native, and his home city is perhaps the one most in need of his guidance. Georgia's travel ball scene has a reputation for being particularly rigorous and taxing on prospects' arms. A recent column by Baseball America editor John Manuel addressed the topic.

"A lot of kids have left their arms at the East Cobb complex," a scout told Manuel. "A lot of clubs are wary of Georgia high school pitchers."

In my area (South Carolina, Georgia), the problem is not in the schools. 

Managers and coaches there do not overwork their pitchers, but I can’t say the same for travel teams around here. They are run (and owned) by money grubbing ex-jocks that could care about the future of these kids. They just want to get into the pocketbooks of the fathers.

            

19 comments:

Tom Brennan said...

Dominic Smith looked trimmer in a recent photo, so I believe he is working out in earnest to put last year's less-than-successful MLB debut in the rear view mirror. Nothing like failure and aging several more months (still 22 until June) to be a springboard to a successful 2018. It is hard for me to believe if, at worst, he is platooned against only righties that he will not hit adequately in 2018.

Gsellman? Last year was mostly disappointing - and then there was the I don't care quote....could be trade bait - if not, another guy who will bounce back with more maturity in 2018. Maybe he is nothing more than an SP 4 or SP 5 - teams need those.

Braves prospects - hopefully, our people saw them play in 2017 already and know what they can do without a showcase.

Schilling should be judged for the Hall on his pitching, not his politics. He never had today's severe offenses - groped anyone or came on to a 14 year old - so vote for him on his baseball skills and career performance.

My lefty brother Steve wrecked his shoulder around age 17 doing exactly that - pitching constantly - he threw a one hitter and fanned 17 in a HS game. No one told him to not overdo it. The dream ended right there.

Dove said...

You all know my thoughts in defense of Dominic Smith. In my humble 2 cent opinion the guy i saw in a lucie mets and once in a 51s uniform is not the same guy who showed up in queens. Whether nerves or too much wrong coaching to force him to pull the ball, its not his game. Hes prob never as a pro hit 9 homers in like 40ish game span like he did because its not his game to force it.
Let him be the. 290 hitting 20ish homer guy he is. Hes only 22 and HE HAS POWER. Maybe he naturally goes into the 25-35 range later.

Tom Brennan said...

Ernest, you most likely are right. I say platoon him with Flores and he should be fine, make him hit against lefties as well starting later in 2018 when the pressure is off, or in 2019.

Mack Ade said...

I still would make 2018 a turnaround and rebuilding year... and give Smith 500+ at-bats at first against both righties and lefties. I would also elevate Peter Alonso to Las Vegas and sharpen his bat while he works on his D.

Tom Brennan said...

Mack, I am 100% with you on Alonso - on Smith, as of right now, I'd wait starting him against lefties until the Mets PROVE it is a sinking season (say 10 games out). If that was last season, his regular at bats against lefties would still have covered most of the season. Until then, play like it is not a rebuild season. Flores kills lefties, Smith struggles against them.

Mack Ade said...

Tom -

Well, in my scenario, the team would operate from day one as a rebuilding team, this, all projected kids like Smith and Rosario go to the head of the class.

Tom Brennan said...

By the end of April, we may be in full rebuild mode, Mack!

Eddie from Corona said...

Gsellman... I prayed we would have won that play in game against the giants, not because I felt we could have made a run but because if Lugo and gsellman actually played well in that setting we could have traded them high...
Knowing us we would have been just as fooled and not traded high...

Smith to me didn’t have a look of a star... sadly my first thoughts of Rosario were the same (this was a top 3/5 talent in all of baseball?)
I would give smith the whole year, lefty’s and righties (with proper rest days but 500 at bats)
But I believe our shot at internal 1b is Alonso...
His power profile fits the 1b model... if he can field like Duda we’re good...

I am also starting the clock on Gimenez... as the SS...

Mack Ade said...

Ticktock...

Tom Brennan said...

Eddie, Giminez was remarkable at SS for an 18 year old. We cannot automatically assume Rosario has that locked down in 2 years.

Tom Brennan said...

Amazing, for all the flak Gsellman gets, he is just 24 and 12-9, 4.44 as a major leaguer. Compare to recent Zach Wheeler and Matt Harvey.

Robb said...

My thoughts about schilling is he's a borderline HoF guy, probably deserves to get in. Same way Jack Morris probably deserves to get in, but Id vote for Mussina first. That being said, if you arent a slam dunk and the HoF voters think youre a dick, you're going to struggle to get anyone vote for you over a guy who is of nearly equal value, but whom people like.

eddie Murray was a slam dunk HoF guy, but bc of how awful he was to be around, it took a minute for him to get in.

The thing about schilling is so far since he's retired everything he has done has made him look less appealing, from being politically outspoken, to wasting 60 million of tax payer money in the areas that should be leading his his campaign. Not that this should matter, but it does. I mean Piazza was way more a lock to get in and it took a couple years with the roids rumors and the voters like him. To me this is less about his politics then being outspoken about everything, just stfu if you want to get in and let the stats/memories speak for themselves. alas, he did not do that.

I have high hopes for Dom Smith, I think he has a Hosmer comp personally, so if he can control the weight, he'll be a good player.

LongTimeFan1 said...

Ernest Dove and others advocating for Smith to start:

Smith's says it was his idea to focus on homers in the majors recognizing the long ball has more value in the majors. Says singles just no longer have the same appeal although he'll take them too.

He says he's going to do better job focusing at the plate, making contact and laying off bad pitches.

But if anyone's seeking the pre-major league Dom Smith who doesn't care about power - that's not going to happen.

I agree with Ernest - Smith fits the 20-25 profile.

Perhaps even 25-30. If he's a balanced hitter with balanced approach using whole field with good plate discipline, reducing K's, and hitting where it's pitched, the rest of his offense will elevate, reduce home run rate but make him a far better hitter.

I think, he's determined learn from his mistakes. Whether he does, or can - we don't know.

There's no guarantee he'll have opportunity to win a starting job in the spring. Or if he does - whether it will be with the Mets. Mets are determined to add a first baseman this off season. Whether part time, full time, or fallback option - remains to be seen. This isn't rebuild season. Mets want to reach the postseason.

Meanwhile, Smith has yet to show sustained committment to weight control and fitness since turning pro - a very foolish decision. It puts his career on the line should he continue to play fat and out of shape.

What he proved in the majors is that the game is too fast for him on offense and defense. And that he's too fat to run the bases the way he should. I'll believe he's serious about his conditioning and diet only when he sticks to it for several years and sustains the body of a pro athlete rather than middle aged couch potato. He's made promises before he couldn't sustain.

Anonymous said...

Are some of you really giving up on Smith and Rosario already? They are both BABIES developmentally and predictably struggled in their first extended look at ML pitching.

What happened to a learning curve? How about a little patience?

Boy, the "twitter" - "what have you done for me lately" attitude has really taken hold.

Reese Kaplan said...

My comp for Dom Smith is John Olerud. He was a solid singles/doubles hitter with 20 HR power and slick fielding.

Rosario? He's probably in the Jose Reyes mold, but hopefully will mature.

LongTimeFan1 said...

I detest Curt Schilling's arrogance and viewpoints.

I didn't like the personality either when he pitched, but it's since exponentially grown in light of the comments and regressive politics.

But if I was a Hall of Fame voter and thought he had Hall of Fame career, I'd hold my nose and vote him in. I don't believe he had enough consistent and sustained success for entry.

His first sub 3 era as full time starter occurred in his age 30 season.

His next two - a career total of 3 - occurred at 34 and 36.

He was atop the leaderboard in K's, twice.


He had no Cy Youngs although was twice runner up.

Compare to Randy Johnson who dominated one way or another over the long haul starting with his age 28 season.

5 Cy Youngs and reams of strikeout titles.

LongTimeFan1 said...

To Anonymous at 1:04 pm:


Smith would unlikely be in the situation he's in having to earn a 25 man roster spot, let alone starting job had he opted for fitness.

This has been issue his entire pro career - an element that's impacted every phase of his game. He set the conditions that now lead the Mets to pursue outside help knowing that Smith's untrustworthy in this matter. Mets have playoff aspirations and cannot thus depend on Smith who did not demonstrate the tools of a major leaguer capable of matching the speed of the major league game. He proved power and good human being - but not what he needs to inherit a job.

Rosario has those tools and fitness, hence goes into 2018 as the starting shortstop.

Smith must lose the weight, get fit and stay fit and then prove he belongs. He created his own obstacles and now he's looking at those consequences.

bill metsiac said...

With all the talk about what he should've focused on in his offseason workouts, where is the responsibility of the org?

I don't expect a 20 year old to analyze all his faults and decide what to do about them. We have a system that includes trainers, coaches, mgrs and roving instructors.

What have they told him to focus on, and what did he do with that plan?

If he went against the plan on his own, someone should have sat him down and set him straight. If he was not given direction, jeads above his should roll. If he was given a plan and followed it, then whoever set it up should be accountable.

bill metsiac said...
This comment has been removed by the author.